Thinking Beyond “Rainbow-Washing”
LGBTQIA+ inclusivity is hardly a new watchword, but many organizations still struggle to embrace this despite updated legislation and more accessible guidelines than ever. In this guide we'll discuss how to move a business beyond the "rainbow washing" of just putting up flags during Pride Month, and how to turn into a fully inclusive business to make sure you aren't missing out on talented workers now or in the future.
A guide for employers on LGBTQIA+ compliance, support and inclusivity in the modern workplace
Is your business doing enough to promote workplace inclusivity for LGBTQIA workers? Find out with the ultimate guide for 2021 and beyond. We’ll cover:
- Why it matters now more than ever
- Gender identification rights and obligations
- Responsibilities of a modern employer
- Identifying and responding to poor inclusivity at work
- Key steps to success
Now more than ever, human interactions are the central ingredient in the recipe for sustained business success. As an employer or HR director, workplace inclusivity should be a priority at all times. It’s worth remembering that, by definition, those words should extend to every demographic. Not least the LGBTQIA community.
Knowing how to support LGBTQIA individuals in the workplace isn’t always easy if you’re a member of the heterosexual community (it can pretty difficult even when you identify as LGBTQIA yourself), but this guide will answer all of your key questions on the subject, such as;
- What regulations are in place to protect LGBTQIA workers?
- What benefits can your company gain from investing in LGBTQIA support?
- How can you avoid discrimination in the workplace?
- How should your company respond to bullying or customer-based issues?
- What gender identification rights should you support?
Sound good? Then read on…
Why LGBTQIA issues matter
Most people already appreciate that there is a growing expectation for companies to deliver workplace inclusivity for all. However, adapting protocols simply because “you should” is the wrong mindset to take. Understanding why LGBTQIA issues matter for workers and how they can benefit the business will make you want to improve.
Here are just some of the aspects you need to consider.
- At 6%, a greater percentage of the population identify as LGBTQIA than ever before.
- The generational shift is clear, with 1 in 6 members of Gen Z identifying as LGBTQIA individuals.
- While the U.S is more liberal than many countries, the acceptance rate is still only at 72%.
- The Matthew Shepard Act, which outlaws gender hate crimes, was introduced in July 2009.
- Both college graduates (6%) and non-college graduates (5.7%) have similar LGBTQIA rates.
Furthermore, studies in Britain found that half of LGBTQIA workers have experienced depression at work while over 60% have had anxiety.
With the above statistics in mind, it is almost certain that you will have LGBTQIA workers. Showing that they are valued will ultimately lend itself to increased morale and greater productivity. Moreover, most non-LGBTQIA employees will have friends and relatives that identify this way, which is why most of your workforce actively cares about these issues.
In addition to supporting your workforce, it should not be forgotten that the U.S. LGBTQIA community has a combined spending power of over $917bn. The majority will want to align themselves with companies that they can relate to. Are you really in a position to miss out on an audience that large? Exactly.
The evidence is clear: now is the time to ensure that you meet legal obligations and provide the necessary level of workplace inclusion and representation.
What gender identification rights and obligations currently exist?
Ever since its inception, the Department of Labor (DoL) has been committed to promoting equality and diversity in the American workplace. Its mission statement reads:
Our nation and workforce are stronger when we embrace diversity, and when workers can apply their unique skills and talents to jobs that provide fair wages, benefits, and safe and healthy working conditions and ensure respectful inclusion.
Moreover, workers are supported by governing bodies like OSHA, as well as the Civil Rights Act. So, what protections are in place in relation to the LGBTQIA community? Some of the key factors to consider include:
- As per the Civil Rights Act 1964, organizations with 15 or more employees cannot discriminate against employees or job candidates based on their sex, gender identity, or sexuality. Many states and territories have their own rules in place to underline this further.
- As of June 2020, U.S. workers cannot be dismissed from their employment based on their sexuality or gender identity either, which is in line with the Civil Rights Act 1964 too.
- Since 2014, the Executive Order 13672, has included the term “gender identity”, providing LGBTQIA workers with the same recruitment protections as all other contractors and employees.
- Gender identity and sexuality are also protected under the Equality Act, allowing employees to seek the same benefits and treatments as all others.
- While no direct laws exist to prevent discrimination of this kind against consumers and the public, state and local laws may exist.
- DoL laws state that individuals who are in the process of transition are entitled to sick leave. Meanwhile, the Family Medical Leave Act can be executed in relation to transitioning.
Regulations are ultimately in place to ensure that LGBTQIA workers are given equal opportunities to find employment and keep their roles. Similar rules exist in various countries around the globe. For example, the UK Unison rules show that LGBT employees are protected under the Equality Act 2010.
In Australia, LGBTQIA workers are protected by the Sex Discrimination Act 1984, which covers all types of gender discrimination and harassment, as well as the generic Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986.
Legal protections exist to guide employers, support employees and set standardized practices that create fairer environments. Employers and senior execs have a legal and human responsibility to implement winning strategies throughout their businesses. Not least because it’s good for business.
Further Developments For The Future
In January 2021, President Joe Biden signed an executive order ending the ban on military service for transgender people. Away from the workplace, 2021 has already seen commercial surrogacy become legal for same-sex couples while the option for healthcare companies to discriminate against gay or transgender patients was overturned too.
It all suggests that the country is heading in the right direction while similar changes are occurring around the world. For example, the European Union has announced itself as a ‘Freedom Zone’ for LGBTQIA communities.
Nonetheless, regulatory and government changes count for little if they are not followed by employers. It is possible to invest in an internal policy that actively invites more LGBTQIA candidates to apply and attend interviews. However, individuals should not be forced to disclose this information. More importantly, then, you must simply learn to park any preconceptions at the door.
Responsibilities of a modern employer
Updates to the terminology of the Civil Rights Act, Executive Order 113672, and Equality Act are just three examples of the goalposts moving to encourage a more inclusive workplace. So, that must mean LGBTQIA workers are now treated 100% fairly, right? If only…
The Out Of Office studies show a huge disparity exists in the general employment rights and opportunities from one part of the country to another. If you are committed to creating a more inclusive workplace, you need to accept your responsibilities as an employer.
To achieve this, you must learn to think like an LGBTQIA employee or applicant. Knowing their rights will ultimately allow you to satisfy your responsibilities. Key aspects include;
- All employees have the right to be called by the name and pronouns that they are most comfortable with.
- Every worker has the right to privacy and confidentiality in relation to their gender and/or sexuality.
- Employees must be protected against harassment of any kind from all internal sources within the organization.
The great news is that you will be rewarded for making those efforts. One-quarter of LGBTQIA workers stay in a job because of an inclusive workplace while one in ten leave roles for the exact opposite reason.
Meanwhile, as the understanding of LGBTQIA issues grows in alignment with the increased identification among the population, new tools become available. A great example is the Pride at Work Canada’s LGBTQ2+ Workplace Inclusion Index, which helps employers track their diversity and workplace inclusion by answering a survey of 35 questions. New resources regularly enter the marketplace.
Responsibilities Concerning Transitioning Workers
Only 0.3% of Fortune 500 board directors are openly LGBTQIA. While the figure is a little higher when looking at all businesses, there is no question that the community is underrepresented at the very highest levels. And transgender people face even greater underrepresentation.
An understanding boss or HR team will help overcome many of their problems. Aside from simply trying to provide a more inclusive environment, you must recognize the rights of transitioning workers. The most telling are;
- Employees who transition or make legal changes are entitled to have their Official Personnel Folder (OPF) documents updated to reflect their new identity.
- If a person is living as the gender they identify as all federal workplaces must provide restroom facilities concerning their identified gender.
- Transgender workers should have the right to privacy and should not feel forced into discussing their transitioning (except for time off requests) or sexuality to anyone.
- If a transgender person is happy to talk about their gender, any questions should be made in a respectful manner.
- Workers undergoing a transition must be supported with their appearance by being able to dress in a way that aligns with their gender, without breaking the dress code.
Like gay and lesbian workers, transgender people do not need preferential treatment. They simply want an equal opportunities working environment.
Communicating With Colleagues
Employers, CEOs, directors, and HR teams should all aim to lead by example. However, it’s not all about the employer-employee relationship. You are a busy senior exec who shares very limited time with individual workers. The interactions with other colleagues are far more common, and subsequently hold a huge influence on an employee’s happiness, motivation, and productivity.
Studies show that LGBTQIA workers face more cases of harassment than others. This includes micro-aggressions, sexual harassment, and hearing jokes about them. Moreover, the female workers seem to have it worse, although the males are far from exempt.
Therefore, you must make this a company-wide commitment. The following steps will enable you to do this;
- Actively send all employees on appropriate training courses that cover all aspects of suitable workplace conduct. This should cover LGBTQIA issues, as well as sexism, racism, and any other forms of workplace inequality.
- Highlight that it is not acceptable for workers to engage in gossip, rumors, or any form of bullying in the workplace. You can also make employees sign a Code of Conduct or similar document.
- Encourage victims to speak up about any aggressions they may experience while simultaneously building an inclusive environment where non-victims feel confident speaking up and challenging wrong behaviors on behalf of colleagues.
- Utilize any opportunity to use work outings or team building sessions to unite your entire workforce, including workers from all backgrounds. This can include team away days.
- Have regular reviews of the policies, and use simple online quizzes to ensure that all workers understand the rules and the importance of maintaining an environment that offers equality for all.
This isn’t an issue restricted to America, though. In Australia, for example, 80% of homophobic abuse happens in schools while 60% of LGBTQIA members have experienced verbal abuse or worse. It teaches us that communities need to be taught about inclusiveness. Regardless of where your offices are based, you must take it upon yourself to provide this education.
Your reward? Aside from doing what’s right for your LGBTQIA employees, it goes a long way to building a stronger team. Given that workers are the greatest asset at any company’s disposal, you’d be a fool to ignore those benefits.
How to identify and respond to poor workplace inclusivity
Did you know that 72% of sexual harassment cases in the workplace go unreported? It’s a scary statistic right? Well, discrimination linked to gender identity is an equally problematic issue.
The situation has improved drastically, not least when compared to the intolerance in other parts of the world. Same-sex marriages remain prohibited in over 70 countries while transgender rights are often non-existent in those nations. Nonetheless, it would be wrong to think that the situation in America is perfect.
Systematic and structural discrimination still exists, both consciously and subconsciously. It is the reason why almost half of LGBTQIA workers feel that they cannot fully express themselves at work while 1 in 5 has been told (or at least implied) to dress differently. Similarly, in Britain, 12% of gay, lesbian, and bi workers admit they would not report bullying while 21% of transgender people feel the same.
The chief reason for victims suffering in silence is quite simply that they do not think anything will be done. Even when policies are in place, many companies are guilty of using workplace inclusivity as a vanity project rather than one that is designed to create an equal environment.
Feeling a little bad about that? Now is the time to put things right, Here’s how.
Familiarize Yourself With What Bullying Actually Is
Workplace bullying and harassment doesn’t have to include physical abuse or shouting obscenities. Microaggressions are the most common forms of bullying, with a reported 83% of workers (not just LGBTQIA) experiencing it at some stage.
So, it’s important to recognize the various signs of bullying. Some are subtle while others are far more obvious. The list includes;
- Deceit, often followed by rationalization or intimidation.
- Exclusion, minimization, and undermining work.
- Manipulation and pitting workers against each other.
- Mood swings, projection of blame, and inconsistent actions.
- Diversion, or taking credit for someone’s work.
- Threats and offensive communication like coercion.
- Campaigning to oust another person.
- Vindictive behaviors, belittlement, and punishment.
By understanding bullying, you don’t just support LGBTQIA workers. You create an inclusive environment for everyone.
Identifying LGBTQIA Inequality
Even with a supportive network, a lot of victims won’t make the first move. That’s just the way things are after generations of systematic inequality – and it’s not a problem that is restricted to LGBTQIA issues either.
Up until the changes in 2020, over 52% of the LGBTQIA community lived in states where no laws against gender-specific discrimination were in place. This is an issue that has impacted workers around the globe too.
For example, a major study into EU countries found that while progress is made, further developments are still needed. One of the key findings was that “(LGBTQIA) people also think that ‘positive changes in law and policy’ and ‘support by public figures and civil society’ lower discrimination”.
Therefore, it’s vital that you take a proactive approach to spot the signs. You must look for symptoms that someone isn’t in the right frame of mind. Use your network of HR staff and team leaders to look for common symptoms, such as;
- A worker has become indecisive.
- An LGBTQIA worker is more reserved and is no longer open about their gender when they previously were.
- The worker is unable to cope with tasks despite previously showing their capabilities.
- There is a clear lack of alertness or visible exhaustion.
- They suffer burnout far too quickly.
- An LGBTQIA worker has become irritable, even with supportive colleagues that they usually share a good relationship with.
- They start to take days off, with or without prior warning.
- There is reduced efficiency in the workplace, as well as confusion and signs of anxiety.
- A previously loud LGBTQIA worker has become more reserved in the way they dress or interact with colleagues.
- The worker avoids making their voice heard in team meetings and other settings.
None of the individual signs necessarily mean that your workers are experiencing homophobia or bullying in the workplace. There are plenty of alternative explanations. Nonetheless, you must not ignore those symptoms either.
While it’s not directly linked to work, 40% of LGBTQIA youths contemplate suicide due to a lack of inclusion and the sense of helplessness. A lack of support certainly feeds into this problem, and it continues into adulthood. Even when a worker isn’t at risk of taking such drastic action, feeling alone on their journey can lead to mental health issues.
How To Respond To Workplace Bullying Against LGBTQIA
As mentioned, LGBTQIA groups seek equality over preferential treatment. Subsequently, then, many of the responses are no different to workplace inequality of any kind. Nonetheless, half of all workers from this community report moderate to significant psychological impacts, which is why you must respond well.
After putting the right preparations in place, you might have hoped that future situations would be avoided altogether. Unfortunately, things aren’t quite that easy (just ask literally any member of the LGBTQIA community) and issues may continue to surface from time to time. Here’s how to tackle them.
- Always remove blame from the victim to show solidarity.
- Conduct a full investigation into the matter, keeping a record of all findings to display your commitment to workplace inclusion.
- Implement disciplinary measures, as stated as a part of your workplace inclusion goals, against the guilty party.
- Invest in a refresher training course for all employees to force home the message of workplace inclusivity for all.
- Conduct employee surveys and clear discussions to analyze the current levels of diversity awareness.
- If required, seek professional legal advice to ensure that official complaints are handled correctly.
Ultimately, your goals are to stamp out workplace bullying with immediate effect while showing LGBTQIA victims that you are committed to building a better working environment. At the same time, you should let all workers know that inequality will not be tolerated. 86% of businesses state that implementing non-discrimination policies cost nothing or next to nothing. That means there are no real excuses for ignoring this any longer.
We are living in 2021. And it is about time that employers and HR teams embraced it. The post-pandemic era offers the perfect opportunity to update outdated methods and ideologies that have harmed your business or left workers to feel excluded from the company.
To recap, the following steps will lead you to success;
- Take it upon yourself to understand LGBTQIA issues – and not just the legal obligations of an employer.
- Lead by example by creating an inclusive workspace for all workers, including LGBTQIA and other underrepresented groups.
- Have open discussions with LGBTQIA workers – if they are happy to, and with their privacy kept intact.
- Invest in company-wide training to build a better understanding of LGBTQIA issues and, where required, increased acceptance.
- Stay vigilant to examples of discrimination or workplace bullying – and stamp them out at the earliest stage.
Research shows that 85% of the LGBTQIA community (both consumers and workers) feel that corporations who support them are more important than ever while most non-LGBTQIA groups would agree.
Go the extra mile to get it right from the top, and it will boost your bottom line.